
Italy fines Meta €805 million over Facebook access to Android photo galleries
Italy’s privacy regulator says Facebook accessed photos, videos and metadata without specific consent. It ordered Meta to change the feature within 60 days.
AI-generated editorial illustration supplied for PRESDA.
Italy’s data protection authority fined Meta Platforms Ireland €805 million on November 14, 2026. Reuters put the equivalent at about $887 million. The Garante said Facebook’s Android app accessed photos, videos and associated metadata on Italian users’ devices without obtaining specific consent or adequately explaining the access. The authority considered approximately 20 million Android users in Italy when calculating the sanction. Reuters
How Facebook’s gallery suggestions worked
Introduced in 2023, the feature suggested items from a phone’s gallery that someone might want to post while browsing Facebook. The regulator found that the app used one broad permission for multiple features and described it in general terms. Gallery suggestions were on by default. An unrestricted grant, the authority said, could allow ongoing reading of the full photo library without showing users which items were actually used. Italian Data Protection Authority
Why Italy’s regulator took the case
The decision applies Article 122 of Italy’s privacy code, which implements the EU ePrivacy Directive. The Garante focused on access to information stored on the handset. It rejected Meta’s argument for handling the case in Ireland, saying the ePrivacy rules lack the one-stop-shop mechanism used for certain cross-border GDPR cases. Italian Data Protection Authority
Why an Android permission was only part of the question
A phone’s permission control answers whether the operating system will let an app read particular files. The regulator examined a second decision: whether someone understood and agreed to Facebook’s use of that access to suggest items while browsing. According to the Garante, a single permission served several purposes and the notice did not tell people clearly that agreeing also enabled gallery suggestions. The feature’s default setting made the distinction consequential even for people who never selected a photo to publish. Source · Garante Privacy, decision summary
What access does, and what the ruling establishes
A user can open a publishing tool to choose an image. A suggestion tool may instead scan available material in order to decide what to recommend. The authority focused on that second use. It said a full grant gave the app continuing access to the gallery, while users and the authority could not verify which records were actually used. The finding concerns access to information stored on the device. It does not establish that all files were copied or that each Android user identified in the penalty calculation was individually affected. Source · Garante Privacy, decision summary
How the three deadlines fit together
The order sets separate milestones for reporting initial action, changing the feature and reporting what has been done. The default-off requirement applies even to people who previously gave the operating system permission. A fresh, specific choice must explain what the feature does and how to turn it off. If the deadline passes without compliance, activation for users without valid consent is barred. The timeline below describes the published order, rather than the status of Meta’s compliance. Source · Garante Privacy, decision summary
| Deadline | What Meta must do |
|---|---|
| 30 days | Notify the Garante of steps begun |
| 60 days | Ask for separate consent and leave the feature off by default |
| 90 days | Report the measures taken |
Why the fine was large and how Meta responded
The regulator weighed the scale and duration, a previous measure from 2019 and what it described as limited cooperation during the inquiry. It gave some weight to changes made after the complaint, while saying those changes came late and depended on an app update. Meta disputed the decision and told Reuters it intended to appeal. These are distinct claims: the authority has publicly imposed the fine, and the company has publicly stated the position it plans to take. Follow the history of Facebook and Meta for the wider company context. Source · Garante Privacy, decision summary Source · Reuters, Meta response
What Meta must change
The authority gave Meta 60 days to turn off the feature by default, seek separate consent, and explain how to disable it. Meta must report initial steps within 30 days and measures taken within 90. The decision leaves potential AI training outside its scope, and the regulator reserved separate scrutiny of a cloud-based feature introduced in 2026. Italian Data Protection Authority
The Garante said the inquiry began in July 2025 after a complaint from a consumer organisation in Bolzano. The case asks whether someone understood what Facebook would do with access already granted to the app. The separate consent order addresses that gap directly. Euronews
What the fine measures
The €805 million sanction amounted to approximately 0.47% of Meta’s global turnover, according to the regulator. Its estimate of about 20 million Android users in Italy describes the scale it considered. It cannot establish which personal files were read or how many individuals’ files were accessed. The underlying finding concerned the way the app asked users for permission and used that access for a distinct feature. Source · garanteprivacy.it
Meta’s response and the scope of the decision
Italian news agency ANSA reported that Meta was preparing an appeal. An appeal is a procedural step distinct from the authority’s published findings. The Garante’s announcement sets out the deadlines for changing the in-app feature. It also reserves scrutiny of a later cloud-based feature. Those are separate questions about the design and processing of two features, and the regulator’s ruling on one does not determine the result of any inquiry into the other. Source · ansa.it Source · garanteprivacy.it
Related coverage
FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions
How much was the fine?
€805 million, approximately $887 million as reported by Reuters.
Did the ruling establish that Meta trained AI on the photos?
The decision focused on device access and consent. It did not examine AI training.
PRESDA Dispatch
Stay Informed. Stay Aware.
A sharp briefing across AI, gaming, sport, business, world affairs, paparazzi, and lifestyle.


